There’s a box of California raisins in your pantry right now. Don’t pretend there isn’t. It’s probably tucked behind the olive oil, and it’s been there since early summer, outlasting your sourdough starter even. That box is about to become a raisin pie. For generations, home bakers have been turning a few pantry staples into this pie. Our version gives the classic a California upgrade by simmering the raisins in California dessert wine.

What Is an Old Fashioned Raisin Pie?

An old-fashioned raisin pie is about as simple as baking gets. You simmer raisins in a spiced brown sugar syrup, then bake them between two layers of pie dough until the top turns golden brown.

It makes sense when you think about it. Before refrigeration, fresh fruit was hard to come by for much of the year. Most homes would have kept dried fruit on hand. The ingredients were always there, and the pie kept well, so cooks could bake it a day or two ahead of when they needed it. Every family seems to have its own take. Some add milk or sour cream for a custardy filling, while others stick with water and sometimes add chopped walnuts. Almost everyone, though, agrees on a double crust, sometimes with a lattice top.

If your great-grandmother had a recipe box, some version of this pie recipe probably lived in it. Lots of us have fond memories of a slice on the holiday table, sitting right next to the pumpkin and the pecan pies.

Why We Always Keep California Raisins in the Pantry

We love raisins for a lot of reasons, and staying power is near the top of the list. Raisins stay at peak freshness for up to six months in the pantry and up to a full year in the fridge. Fresh fruit pies have to wait for their season. This one just needs you to remember the box in the cupboard, which is exactly why raisin pie has stuck around so long and why you can bake it any time of year.

Every raisin grown in the United States comes from California, and nearly all of them come from the San Joaquin Valley. They all start out as green grapes. Some growers dry them on paper trays in the vineyard, and others leave them to dry right on the vine. Sun-dried raisins come out brown, while golden raisins are mechanically dried. Either way, you’re getting one ingredient (raisins) with no added sugar.

Many of those raisins come from families who’ve farmed side by side for over a century. Back in 1912, a group of Central Valley raisin growers joined forces as a cooperative, and in 1915 they started calling themselves Sun-Maid, a nod to raisins being made in the sun. Today the co-op represents more than half of California’s raisin farmers. The full story from our visit with Sun-Maid is worth a read, and it even tells you where to find the world’s largest raisin box in Kingsburg.

A Quick Word About the Wine

Raisins and wine both start out as California grapes, so it felt right to put them in the same recipe.

We used a sweet wine from Quady Winery for this pie, but you could also use one of their delicious dessert wines. Quady Winery is in Madera, smack in the middle of the San Joaquin Valley, and they create impeccable wines from Orange and Black Muscat grapes.

Our Twist on the Classic Raisin Pie Recipe

Many classic raisin pie recipes simmer the fruit in plain water. We split the job between two cups of water and a cup of California sweet wine, and it gives the raisin filling a deeper, almost jammy flavor. Place raisins in a small saucepan with the water and wine and let them boil for five minutes. They’re ready when the hot raisins look plump and glossy.

While they cook, mix the brown sugar, cornstarch, cinnamon, and salt in a bowl. Doing this first keeps the cornstarch from clumping when it hits the pot. Stir it into the raisins and keep cooking until the syrup turns thick and almost clear.

Then comes our favorite surprise ingredient. Once the pan is off the heat, stir in two tablespoons of distilled white vinegar along with the butter. That little bit of acid balances the sweetness of the raisin mixture and keeps the pie filling tasting bright.

We used a pie dough recipe from one of the CA GROWN creators, but you can use your favorite double-crust pie dough recipe or keep it easy with store-bought double-crust pastry. Let the filling cool while you line a 9-inch pie plate with the bottom crust, then pour it in. Lay the top crust over the filling and seal the edges. Cut a few slits to let steam escape, add a little egg wash and a sprinkling of sugar, then bake until golden brown.

More Ways to Use Your California Raisins

A raisin pie takes three cups of raisins, so you’ll probably have some left in the bag. Here are a few more of our favorite ways to use them up.

Tips for Making the Best Raisin Pie

Let it cool completely. The filling needs time at room temperature to set; otherwise, that first slice will fall apart and slide right off the server. We know waiting is the hardest part, but clean slices that hold up are worth it.

Want the old-school look? Cut the top crust into strips and weave a lattice. The syrup bubbles up between the strips, and it looks like something straight off a farmhouse calendar.

And don’t skip a scoop of vanilla ice cream if you have some on hand. It melts right into the syrupy raisin filling in the best possible way.

Bring Back the Raisin Pie

Fruit pies tend to get all the attention, but raisin pie has been patiently waiting for its moment. Because the star ingredient keeps for months in the cupboard, this pie works just as well for a holiday spread as it does for a random Thursday.

Need a new soundtrack for your kitchen? Check out this CA GROWN Spotify playlist:

Are you planning on baking a raisin pie? We’d love to see your creations! Share your photos with us by tagging #CAGROWN on social media.

Don’t stop here! Follow us on Pinterest for more fresh and fabulous recipe inspiration. Dive into the world of CA GROWN goodness, and let’s make every meal a celebration of the Golden State’s bounty.